# Denys Griaznov v. MPOWERHealth Holdings, LLC - Filed Class Action Complaint Canonical: https://hallattorneys.com/dockets/mpowerhealth Source PDF: https://hallattorneys.com/dockets/mpowerhealth/01-complaint.pdf Filed: November 20, 2026 Docket entry: ECF No. 1 Case number: 3:26-cv-04097-K Court: U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division Defendant: MPOWERHealth Holdings, LLC The following is extracted text of the original 59-page complaint. Allegations are not findings. No class has been certified. The PDF controls if extraction differs. Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 1 of 59 PageID 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS DALLAS DIVISION DENYS GRIAZNOV, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, Case No. CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT v. JURY DEMAND MPOWERHEALTH HOLDINGS, LLC, Defendant. Plaintiff Denys Griaznov, (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated (the “Class” or “Class Members,” as defined below), by and through his undersigned counsel, files this Class Action Complaint against MPOWERHealth Holdings, LLC (“MPOWERHealth” or “Defendant”) and alleges the following based on personal knowledge of facts, upon information and belief, and based on the investigation of his counsel as to all other matters. I. 1. NATURE OF THE ACTION Plaintiff brings this class action lawsuit against Defendant for its negligent failure to protect and safeguard Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ highly sensitive personally identifiable information1 (“PII”) and protected health information (“PHI”) (collectively, “Private Information”), culminating in a massive and preventable data breach (the “Data Breach” or “Breach”). As a result of Defendant’s failure to implement reasonable and necessary data security 1 Personally identifiable information generally incorporates information that can be used to distinguish or trace an individual’s identity, either alone or when combined with other personal or identifying information. 2 C.F.R. § 200.79. At a minimum, it includes all information that on its face expressly identifies an individual. Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 2 of 59 PageID 2 practices, cybercriminals easily infiltrated Defendant’s inadequately protected computer systems and stole the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members. 2. Defendant MPOWERHealth describes itself as “a healthcare services company dedicated to delivering high-quality, optimized and efficient, value-based surgical support.” According to its website, Defendant partners “with hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers, and surgeons to provide specialized services in Intraoperative Neuromonitoring (IONM) and Surgical Services (Surgical First Assist), as well as Advanced Neurological Services,” including electroencephalography (EEG) and long-term EEG monitoring.2 3. As part of its business practices and to provide services, Defendant collects, stores, and maintains patients’ Private Information, including Plaintiff’s and Class Members’. Plaintiff and Class Members are current and former patients whose Private Information Defendant obtained and maintained in connection with the healthcare services Defendant and its affiliates provide. 4. Between June 23, 2025, and June 26, 2025, an unauthorized party gained access to Defendant’s inadequately protected internal network and accessed and/or acquired files containing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information stored thereon. Defendant has stated that, on or about June 26, 2025, it “detected that an unauthorized party obtained access to a limited portion of [its] internal network.” Upon information and belief, Defendant has not disclosed publicly what threat actor was involved or how the unauthorized party gained entry.3 5. Defendant disclosed in its public notice and its notice letters (“Notice Letter”) to affected individuals that the personal information involved in the Breach, which Defendant 2 https://mpowerhealth.com/who-we-are/ (last visited November 20, 2026); see also https://mpowerhealth.com/advanced-neurological-services/ (last visited November 20, 2026). 3 https://mpowerhealth.com/notice-of-data-security-incident/ (last visited November 20, 2026); Exhibit 1. 2 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 3 of 59 PageID 3 acknowledges includes “Protected Health Information as defined by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act,” varied by individual but included at least: first and last names, addresses, phone numbers, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, state/government ID, financial account information, medical record numbers, dates of service, medical provider names, health insurance group and policy numbers, other health insurance information, medical billing and payment for health services information, physical or medical conditions and/or diagnoses, and medical procedure information.4 6. Although Defendant detected the Breach on or about June 26, 2025, Defendant delayed notifying affected individuals until on or about November 13, 2026, nearly seventeen months after it detected the Breach, when it began mailing Notice Letters to affected individuals.5 Defendant’s severe delay in alerting impacted individuals of the Breach prevented Plaintiff and Class Members from taking earlier actions to protect themselves against fraud and misuse of their information. 7. Plaintiff and Class Members provided their Private Information, directly or indirectly, to Defendant with the mutual understanding that Defendant would safeguard their Private Information from unauthorized disclosure and would implement sufficient cybersecurity safeguards to protect such information. 8. Businesses that store and maintain patients’ Private Information, like Defendant, owe the individuals to whom the information relates a duty to adopt reasonable measures to protect it from unauthorized disclosures and unauthorized third parties. This duty arises under contract, statutory and common law, industry standards, representations made to Plaintiff and Class 4 5 Exhibit 1 Id. 3 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 4 of 59 PageID 4 Members, and because it is foreseeable that the exposure of Private Information to unauthorized persons, and especially hackers, will harm the affected individuals, including to the invasion of their private information and financial matters. 9. In providing their Private Information to Defendant, Plaintiff and the Class Members reasonably expected this sophisticated business entity to keep their Private Information confidential and secured from unauthorized disclosures, to use this information for business purposes only, and to disclose it only as authorized. Defendant failed to do so, resulting in the unauthorized disclosure of Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information in the Breach. 10. Defendant failed to adequately protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information and failed to ensure that it would maintain adequate safeguards to protect its patients’ Private Information. 11. Upon information and belief, Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information is in the hands of cybercriminals who will continue to use the stolen Private Information for nefarious purposes for the rest of their lives. 12. Due to Defendant’s negligent failure to secure and protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, cybercriminals have stolen and obtained everything they need to commit identity theft and wreak havoc on the financial and personal lives of thousands of individuals. 13. Now, and for the rest of their lives, Plaintiff and the Class Members will have to deal with the danger of identity thieves possessing and misusing their Private Information. Even those Class Members who have yet to experience identity theft will have to spend time responding to the Data Breach and are at an immediate and heightened risk of all manners of identity theft as a direct and proximate result of the Data Breach. 4 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 14. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 5 of 59 PageID 5 Plaintiff and Class Members have incurred and will continue to incur damages in the form of, among other things, identity theft, attempted identity theft, lost time and expenses mitigating harms, increased risk of harm, damaged credit, diminution of the value of their Private Information, loss of privacy, and additional damages as described below. 15. Plaintiff brings this action individually and on behalf of the Class, seeking compensatory damages, punitive damages, nominal damages, restitution, injunctive and declaratory relief, reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs, and all other remedies this Court deems just and proper. II. 16. THE PARTIES Plaintiff Denys Griaznov is an individual domiciled in Cedar Park, Texas. Plaintiff Griaznov received a Notice Letter from Defendant dated November 13, 2026, informing him that his sensitive personal information was involved in the Breach. See Exhibit 1. 17. Defendant MPOWERHealth Holdings LLC is a Delaware limited liability company with its headquarters and principal place of business located at 5080 Spectrum Drive, Suite 1100 E, Addison, Texas 75001. Defendant’s service agent is Capitol Services, Inc., which can be served at 108 Lakeland Avenue, Dover, Delaware 19901. III. 18. JURISDICTION AND VENUE This Court has subject-matter jurisdiction pursuant to the Class Action Fairness Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d) because (1) the matter in controversy exceeds the sum or value of $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs, (2) the action is a class action, (3) at least one Class Member is a citizen of a state different from Defendant,6 which is a citizen of Delaware and Texas 6 The Defendant has so far reported that Class Members reside in at least California, Massachusetts, and Texas. https://oag.ca.gov/ecrime/databreach/reports/sb24-632869 (last visited 5 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 6 of 59 PageID 6 for purposes of 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(10), and (4) there are more than 100 Class Members. 19. This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because its principal place of business is in Texas, it conducts substantial business in Texas, and the acts and omissions giving rise to Plaintiff’s claims occurred in this State. 20. Venue is proper in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1) and (2) because Defendant’s principal place of business is in this District, and a substantial part of the events, acts, and omissions giving rise to Plaintiff’s claims occurred in this District. IV. FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS A. Defendant Collected Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information. 21. Defendant MPOWERHealth Holdings LLC describes itself as “a healthcare services company dedicated to delivering high-quality, optimized and efficient, value-based surgical support.” According to its website, Defendant partners “with hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers, and surgeons to provide specialized services in Intraoperative Neuromonitoring (IONM) and Surgical Services (Surgical First Assist), as well as Advanced Neurological Services,” including electroencephalography (EEG) and long-term EEG monitoring.7 22. As part of its business practices and to provide services, Defendant collects, stores, and maintains the patients’ Private Information, including Plaintiff’s and Class Members’. Plaintiff and Class Members are current and former patients whose Private Information Defendant obtained and maintained in connection with the healthcare services Defendant and its affiliates provide. Nov. 20, 2026); https://www.mass.gov/doc/data-breach-report-2026/download (last visited Nov. 20, 2026); https://oag.my.site.com/datasecuritybreachreport/apex/DataSecurityReportsPage (last visited Nov. 20, 2026). 7 https://mpowerhealth.com/who-we-are/ (last visited November 20, 2026); see also https://mpowerhealth.com/advanced-neurological-services/ (last visited November 20, 2026). 6 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 23. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 7 of 59 PageID 7 Defendant obtains, collects, uses, and derives a benefit from the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members. Defendant uses the Private Information it collects to provide and bill for healthcare services, making a profit therefrom. Defendant would not be able to obtain revenue if not for the acceptance and use of Plaintiff’s and the Class’s Private Information. 24. Defendant would be unable to engage in its regular business activities without collecting and aggregating Private Information it knows and understands to be sensitive and confidential. 25. Upon information and belief, Defendant made promises and representations to its patients, including Plaintiff and Class Members, that the Private Information collected from them would be kept safe and confidential, and that the privacy of that information would be maintained. 26. Class Members who are current and former patients of Defendant paid, directly or indirectly, for Defendant’s services, and Defendant made a profit from their services. Defendant promised data security to its patients as part of its services, and a portion of the revenue earned from its patients should have been specifically allocated to data security. 27. By obtaining, collecting, using, and deriving a benefit from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, Defendant assumed legal and equitable duties and knew or should have known it was responsible for protecting Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information from unauthorized disclosure. 28. Defendant was aware of these duties and represented to its patients that it would keep their Private Information secure, stating in its Privacy Notice that: Sharing: We [will] share personal information about visitors to our website with third parties only in the ways that are described in this Privacy Notice. [MPOWERHealth does not sell such personal information to third parties]. [. . .] As a key provider of services and technology to the health care industry, MPOWERHealth has implemented programs to address the privacy and security HIPAA 7 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 8 of 59 PageID 8 requirements. [. . .] We use reasonable and appropriate physical, technical and administrative industry safeguards to protect information from unauthorized access, use, loss, misuse or unauthorized alteration. We will make reasonable efforts to protect personal information stored on the website’s servers from unauthorized access using commercially available computer security products (for example, firewalls), as well as carefully developed security procedures and practices.8 29. Plaintiff and the Class Members reasonably relied on Defendant’s promises to keep their Private Information secure, as Defendant intended 30. Plaintiff and Class Members provided their Private Information, directly or indirectly, to Defendant with the reasonable expectation and on the mutual understanding that Defendant would comply with its obligations to keep such information confidential and secure from unauthorized access. 31. Upon information and belief, Defendant failed to adopt reasonable and appropriate data security practices and procedures including administrative, physical security, and technical controls to safeguard Plaintiff’s and the Class’s Private Information. 32. As a result of collecting and storing the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members for its own financial benefit, Defendant had a continuous duty to adopt and employ reasonable measures to protect Plaintiff’s and the Class Members’ Private Information from disclosure to third parties, and to audit, monitor, and verify the integrity and cybersecurity of its systems storing Private Information. B. Defendant’s Data Breach. 33. Between June 23, 2025, and June 26, 2025, an unauthorized party gained access to Defendant’s inadequately protected internal network and accessed and/or acquired files containing 8 https://mpowerhealth.com/docs/privacy-policy-mpowerhealth.pdf (last visited November 20, 2026). 8 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 9 of 59 PageID 9 Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information stored thereon. Defendant has stated that, on or about June 26, 2025, it “detected that an unauthorized party obtained access to a limited portion of [its] internal network.” Upon information and belief, Defendant has not disclosed publicly what threat actor was involved or how the unauthorized party gained entry.9 34. Defendant disclosed in its public notice and its notice letters (“Notice Letter”) to affected individuals that the personal information involved in the Breach, which Defendant acknowledges includes “Protected Health Information as defined by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act,” varied by individual but included: first and last name, address, phone number, date of birth, Social Security number, driver’s license number, state/government ID, financial account information, medical record number, dates of service, medical provider name, health insurance group and policy numbers, other health insurance information, medical billing and payment for health services information, physical or medical conditions and/or diagnoses, and medical procedure information.10 35. Although Defendant detected the Breach on or about June 26, 2025, Defendant delayed notifying affected individuals until on or about November 13, 2026, nearly seventeen months after it detected the Breach, when it began mailing Notice Letters to affected individuals.11 Defendant’s severe delay in alerting impacted individuals of the Breach prevented Plaintiff and Class Members from taking earlier actions to protect themselves against fraud and misuse of their information. 36. Defendant’s delayed notice of the Breach leaves impacted individuals with no 9 https://mpowerhealth.com/notice-of-data-security-incident/ (last visited November 20, 2026); see also Exhibit 1. 10 Exhibit 1 11 Id. 9 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 10 of 59 PageID 10 information regarding critical facts about the Data Breach, such as details of the root cause of the Breach, the vulnerabilities exploited, when the Breach occurred, and the remedial measures taken by Defendant, if any. 37. Defendant failed to take the necessary precautions required to safeguard and protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information from unauthorized access and exploitation. 38. Defendant failed to timely notify Plaintiff and Class Members of the Data Breach. 39. By collecting, storing, and maintaining the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members, Defendant owed a duty to Plaintiff and Class Members to protect and safeguard their Private Information from unauthorized disclosures. 40. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information was targeted, accessed, and stolen by cybercriminals in the Data Breach. Defendant’s deficient security for patient data caused and allowed criminals to target and take files containing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ inadequately protected, unencrypted Private Information in Defendant’s possession through the Data Breach. 41. Because Defendant had a duty to protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, Defendant should have known through readily available and accessible information about potential threats for the unauthorized exfiltration and misuse of such information. Thus, Defendant had a duty to ensure that patients’ Private Information, stored within its networks and systems, was secured and protected from unauthorized disclosures to third parties. 42. Defendant could and should have prevented this Data Breach by ensuring the files and servers containing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information were properly secured and encrypted but failed to do so. 10 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 43. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 11 of 59 PageID 11 Defendant could have prevented the Data Breach by properly securing and encrypting the files and servers containing the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members. This Data Breach could have been prevented through industry standard network segmentation and encryption of confidential information. Further, the Data Breach could have likely been prevented had Defendant utilized appropriate malware prevention and detection technologies 44. Plaintiff further believes that his Private Information and that of Class Members, was subsequently sold on the dark web following the Data Breach, as that is the modus operandi of cybercriminals that commit cyber-attacks of this type. 45. All in all, Defendant failed to take the necessary precautions required to safeguard and protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information from unauthorized access and exploitation. 46. Defendant’s actions represent a flagrant disregard of the rights of Plaintiff and the Class, both as to privacy and property. 47. As such, Plaintiff and the Class have suffered harm and continue to be at an imminent and impending risk of identity theft and fraud. C. Cyber Criminals Will Use Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information to Defraud them. 48. Private Information is of great value to hackers and cybercriminals, and the data stolen in the Data Breach can and will be used in a variety of ways by criminals to exploit Plaintiff and Class Members and to profit off their misfortune. 11 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 49. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 12 of 59 PageID 12 Each year, identity theft causes tens of billions of dollars of losses to victims in the United States.12 50. For example, with the Private Information stolen in the Data Breach, including Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, financial account information, and medical and health insurance information, identity thieves can commit medical identity theft, fraudulently obtain medical services, treatment, and prescription drugs in a victim’s name, submit fraudulent claims to insurers and government health programs, and many other harmful forms of identity theft. 51. These criminal activities have and will result in devastating financial and personal losses to Plaintiff and Class Members. 52. Medical-related identity theft is one of the most common, most expensive, and most difficult to prevent forms of identity theft. According to Kaiser Health News, “medical-related identity theft accounted for 43 percent of all identity thefts reported in the United States in 2013[,]” which is more than identity thefts involving banking and finance, the government and the military, or education.13 53. “Medical records are a gold mine for criminals—they can access a patient’s name, DOB, Social Security and insurance numbers, and even financial information all in one place.”14 12 Facts + Statistics: Identity Theft and Cybercrime, INSURANCE INFO. INST., https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-identity-theft-and-cybercrime (last visited Feb. 19, 2026). 13 Michael Ollove, The Rise of Medical Identity Theft in Healthcare, Kaiser Health News (Feb. 7, 2014), https://khn.org/news/rise-of-indentity-theft/. 14 You Got It, They Want It: Criminals Targeting Your Private Healthcare Data, New Ponemon Study Shows, IDX (May 14, 2015) https://www.idx.us/knowledge-center/you-got-itthey-want-it-criminals-are-targeting-your-private-healthcare-dat. 12 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 13 of 59 PageID 13 A complete identity theft kit that includes health insurance credentials may be worth up to $1,000 on the black market.15 54. When cybercriminals manage to steal personally sensitive data like Social Security numbers and medical information—as they did here—there is no limit to the amount of fraud to which Plaintiff and Class Members are exposed. 55. Social Security numbers are particularly sensitive pieces of personal information. As the Consumer Federation of America explains: Social Security number. This is the most dangerous type of personal information in the hands of identity thieves because it can open the gate to serious fraud, from obtaining credit in your name to impersonating you to get medical services, government benefits, your tax refunds, employment – even using your identity in bankruptcy and other legal matters. It’s hard to change your Social Security number and it’s not a good idea because it is connected to your life in so many ways.16 (Emphasis added). 56. PII is such a valuable commodity to identity thieves that once it has been compromised, criminals will use it for years.17 57. The Data Breach at issue here was targeted and financially motivated, as the only reason cybercriminals go through the trouble of hacking entities like Defendant is to steal the 15 Managing cyber risks in an interconnected world: Key findings from The Global State of Information Security Survey 2015, PriceWaterhouseCoopers (Sept. 30, 2014), https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/consulting-services/information-security-survey/assets/the-globalstate-of-information-security-survey-2015.pdf. 16 Dark Web Monitoring: What You Should Know, Consumer Federation of America (Mar. 19, 2019), https://consumerfed.org/consumer_info/dark-web-monitoring-what-you-shouldknow/. 17 Personal Information: Data Breaches Are Frequent, but Evidence of Resulting Identity Theft Is Limited; However, the Full Extent Is Unknown, GAO (July 5, 2007), https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-07-737. 13 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 14 of 59 PageID 14 highly sensitive information they maintain, which can be exploited and sold for use in the kinds of criminal activity described herein. 58. A Social Security number, date of birth, and full name can sell for $60 to $80 on the digital black market.18 59. PHI is even more valuable on the black market than PII.19 60. According to the Center for Internet Security, “[t]she average cost of a data breach incurred by a non-healthcare related agency, per stolen record, is $158. For healthcare agencies the cost is an average of $355. Credit card information and PII sell for $1-$2 on the black market, but PHI can sell for as much as $363 according to the Infosec Institute. This is because one’s personal health history, including ailments, illnesses, surgeries, etc., can’t be changed, unlike credit card information or Social Security numbers.”20 61. “PHI is valuable because criminals can use it to target victims with frauds and scams that take advantage of the victim’s medical conditions or victim settlements. It can also be used to create fake insurance claims, allowing for the purchase and resale of medical equipment. Some criminals use PHI to illegally gain access to prescriptions for their own use or resale.”21 18 Michael Kan, Here’s How Much Your Identity Goes for on the Dark Web, PGMag (Nov. 15, 2017), https://www.pcmag.com/news/heres-how-much-your-identity-goes-for-on-thedark-web. 19 Data Breaches: In the Healthcare Sector, Center for Internet Security, https://www.cisecurity.org/insights/blog/data-breaches-in-the-healthcare-sector (last visited Jan. 29, 2026). 20 Id. 21 Id. 14 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 62. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 15 of 59 PageID 15 Identity theft experts advise victims of data breaches: “[I]f there is reason to believe that your personal information has been stolen, you should assume that it can end up for sale on the dark web.”22 63. These risks are both certainly impending and substantial. As the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) has reported, if hackers get access to PII, they will use it.23 64. Hackers may not use the information right away, but this does not mean it will not be used. According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, which conducted a study regarding data breaches: [I]n some cases, stolen data may be held for up to a year or more before being used to commit identity theft. Further, once stolen data have been sold or posted on the Web, fraudulent use of that information may continue for years. As a result, studies that attempt to measure the harm resulting from data breaches cannot necessarily rule out all future harm.24 65. For instance, with a stolen Social Security number, which was information in possession by the Defendant and included in the Breach, criminals can open financial accounts, get medical care, file fraudulent tax returns, commit crimes, and steal benefits.25 22 Dark Web Monitoring: What You Should Know, Consumer Federation of America (Mar. 19, 2019), https://consumerfed.org/consumer_info/dark-web-monitoring-what-you-shouldknow/. 23 Ari Lazarus, How fast will identity thieves use stolen info?, Military Consumer (May 24, 2017), https://www.militaryconsumer.gov/blog/how-fast-will-identity-thieves-use-stoleninfo. 24 Personal Information: Data Breaches Are Frequent, but Evidence of Resulting Identity Theft Is Limited; However, the Full Extent Is Unknown, GAO (July 5, 2007), https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-07-737 (emphasis added). 25 See Nikkita Walker, What Can Someone Do with Your Social Security Number?, Credit.com (Oct. 19, 2023), https://blog.credit.com/2017/11/5-things-an-identity-thief-can-dowith-your-social-security-number-108597/. 15 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 66. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 16 of 59 PageID 16 Identity theft victims must spend countless hours and large amounts of money repairing the impact to their credit as well as protecting themselves in the future.26 67. The unfortunate truth is the full scope of the harm has yet to be realized. There may be a time lag between when harm occurs and when it is discovered, and also between when Private Information is stolen and when it is used. 68. Because a person’s identity is akin to a puzzle with multiple data points, the more accurate pieces of data an identity thief obtains about a person, the easier it is for the thief to take on the victim’s identity, or to track the victim to attempt other hacking crimes against the individual to obtain more data to perfect a crime. 69. For example, armed with just a name and date of birth, a data thief can utilize a hacking technique referred to as “social engineering” to obtain even more information about a victim’s identity, such as a person’s login credentials or Social Security number. Social engineering is a form of hacking whereby a data thief uses previously acquired information to manipulate and trick individuals into disclosing additional confidential or personal information through means such as spam phone calls and text messages or phishing emails. Data breaches are often the starting point for these additional targeted attacks on the victims. 70. One such example of criminals piecing together bits and pieces of compromised Private Information for profit is the development of “Fullz” packages.27 26 Guide for Assisting Identity Theft Victims, Federal Trade Commission (Sept. 2013), https://www.global-screeningsolutions.com/Guide-for-Assisting-ID-Theft-Victims.pdf. 27 “Fullz” is fraudster speak for data that includes the information of the victim, including, but not limited to, the name, address, credit card information, social security number, date of birth, and more. As a rule of thumb, the more information you have on a victim, the more money that can be made off those credentials. Fullz are usually pricier than standard credit card credentials, commanding up to $100 per record (or more) on the dark web. Fullz can be cashed out (turning credentials into money) in various ways, including performing bank transactions over the phone with the required authentication details in-hand. Even “dead Fullz,” which are Fullz credentials 16 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 71. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 17 of 59 PageID 17 With “Fullz” packages, cyber-criminals can cross-reference two sources of Private Information to marry unregulated data available elsewhere to criminally stolen data with an astonishingly complete scope and degree of accuracy to assemble complete dossiers on individuals. 72. The development of “Fullz” packages means here that the stolen Private Information from the Data Breach can easily be used to link and identify it to Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ phone numbers, email addresses, and other unregulated sources and identifiers. In other words, even if certain information such as emails, phone numbers, or credit card numbers may not be included in the Private Information that was exfiltrated in the Data Breach, criminals may still easily create a Fullz package and sell it at a higher price to unscrupulous operators and criminals (such as illegal and scam telemarketers) over and over. Then, this comprehensive dossier can be sold—and then resold in perpetuity—to crooked operators and other criminals (like illegal and scam telemarketers). 73. Identity thieves can also use an individual’s personal data and Private Information to obtain a driver’s license or official identification card in the victim’s name but with the thief’s picture; use the victim’s name and Social Security number to obtain government benefits; or file a fraudulent tax return using the victim’s information. In addition, identity thieves may obtain a job using the victim’s information, rent a house or receive medical services in the victim’s name, and associated with credit cards that are no longer valid, can still be used for numerous purposes, including tax refund scams, ordering credit cards on behalf of the victim, or opening a “mule account” (an account that will accept a fraudulent money transfer from a compromised account) without the victim’s knowledge. See, e.g., Brian Krebs, Medical Records for Sale in Underground Stolen from Texas Life Insurance Firm, Krebs on Security (Sep. 18, 2014), https://krebsonsecuritv.com/2014/09/ medical-records-for-sale-in-underground-stolen-fromtexas-life-insurance-firm 17 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 18 of 59 PageID 18 may even give the victim’s personal information to police during an arrest resulting in an arrest warrant issued in the victim’s name.28 74. Victims of identity theft can suffer from both direct and indirect financial losses. According to a research study published by the Department of Justice, A direct financial loss is the monetary amount the offender obtained from misusing the victim’s account or personal information, including the estimated value of goods, services, or cash obtained. It includes both out-of-pocket loss and any losses that were reimbursed to the victim. An indirect loss includes any other monetary cost caused by the identity theft, such as legal fees, bounced checks, and other miscellaneous expenses that are not reimbursed (e.g., postage, phone calls, or notary fees). All indirect losses are included in the calculation of out-of-pocket loss.29 75. Plaintiff and Class Members will need to pay for their own identity theft protection and credit monitoring for the rest of their lives due to Defendant’s negligence. 76. Furthermore, identity monitoring services only alert someone to the fact that they have already been the victim of identity theft—it does not prevent identity theft.30 77. Nor can an identity monitoring service remove personal information from the dark web.31 28 Identity Theft and Your Social Security Number, Social Security Administration, 1 (2018), https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10064.pdf. 29 Erika Harrell, Bureau of Just. Stat., U.S. DEP’T OF JUST., NCJ 256085, Victims of Identity Theft, 2018 I (2020) https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/vit18.pdf. 30 See Kayleigh Kulp, Credit monitoring services may not be worth the cost, CNBC (Nov. 30, 2017, 9:00 AM), https://www.cnbc.com/2017/11/29/credit-monitoring-services-may-not-beworth-the-cost.html. 31 Dark Web Monitoring: What You Should Know, Consumer Federation of America (Mar. 19, 2019), https://consumerfed.org/consumer_info/dark-web-monitoring-what-you-shouldknow/. 18 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 78. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 19 of 59 PageID 19 “The people who trade in stolen personal information [on the dark web] won’t cooperate with an identity theft service or anyone else, so it’s impossible to get the information removed, stop its sale, or prevent someone who buys it from using it.”32 79. As a direct and proximate result of the Data Breach, Plaintiff and the Class have been damaged and placed at an imminent and continuing increased risk of harm from fraud and identity theft. Plaintiff and the Class must now take the time and effort to mitigate the actual and potential impact of the Data Breach on their everyday lives, including placing “freezes” and “alerts” with credit reporting agencies, contacting their financial institutions, closing or modifying financial accounts, and closely reviewing and monitoring bank accounts, credit reports, and medical records for unauthorized activity for years to come. 80. Even more serious is the identity restoration that Plaintiff and other Class Members must go through, which can require spending countless hours filing police reports, filling out IRS forms, completing Federal Trade Commission checklists and Department of Motor Vehicle driver’s license replacement applications, and calling financial institutions to cancel fraudulent credit applications, to name just a few of the steps Plaintiff and the Class must take. 81. Plaintiff and the Class have or will experience the following concrete and particularized harms for which they are entitled to compensation, including: a. Actual identity theft; b. Trespass, damage to, and theft of their personal property, including their Private Information; c. Improper disclosure and theft of their Private Information; 32 Id. 19 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 20 of 59 PageID 20 d. The imminent and certainly impending injury flowing from potential fraud and identity theft posed by their Private Information being placed in the hands of criminals; e. Loss of privacy suffered as a result of the Data Breach, including the harm of knowing cybercriminals have their Private Information; f. Ascertainable losses in the form of time taken to respond to identity theft, including lost opportunities and lost wages from uncompensated time off from work; g. Ascertainable losses in the form of out-of-pocket expenses and the value of their time reasonably expended to remedy or mitigate the effects of the Data Breach; h. Ascertainable losses in the form of diminution of the value of Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, for which there is a well-established and quantifiable national and international market; i. The loss of use of and access to their credit, accounts, and/or funds; j. Damage to their credit due to fraudulent use of their Private Information; and/or k. Increased cost of borrowing, insurance, deposits, and the inability to secure more favorable interest rates because of a reduced credit score. 82. Moreover, Plaintiff and Class Members have an interest in ensuring that their Private Information, which remains in the possession of Defendant, is protected from further breaches through the implementation of industry standard security measures and safeguards. Defendant has shown itself wholly incapable of protecting Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information. 83. Plaintiff and Class Members also have an interest in ensuring that their Private Information is removed from all Defendant’s servers, systems, and files. 20 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 84. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 21 of 59 PageID 21 Plaintiff and Class Members are desperately trying to mitigate the damages Defendant caused them. 85. Given the kind of Private Information Defendant made accessible to hackers, however, Plaintiff and the Class are certain to incur additional damages. Because identity thieves have their Private Information, Plaintiff and Class Members will need to have identity theft monitoring protection for the rest of their lives. Some may even need to go through the long and arduous process of getting a new Social Security number, with all the loss of credit and employment difficulties that come with a new number.33 86. None of this should have happened because the Data Breach was entirely preventable. D. Defendant was Aware—or Should Have Been Aware—of the Risk of Cyberattacks. 87. According to the Center for Internet Security, “the health industry experiences more data breaches than any other sector.”34 This is because “Personal Health Information (PHI) is more valuable on the black market than credit card credentials or regular Personally Identifiable Information (PII). Therefore, there is a higher incentive for cyber criminals to target medical databases. They can sell the PHI and/or use it for their own personal gain.”35 88. “In 2023, more than 540 organizations and 112 million individuals were implicated in healthcare data breaches reported to the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR), compared to 590 33 What happens if I change my Social Security number?, Lexington Law (Aug. 10, 2022), https://www.lexingtonlaw.com/blog/credit-101/will-a-new-social-security-number-affectyour-credit.html. 34 Data Breaches: In the Healthcare Sector, Center for Internet Security, https://www.cisecurity.org/insights/blog/data-breaches-in-the-healthcare-sector (last visited April 11, 2024). 35 Id. 21 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 22 of 59 PageID 22 organizations and 48.6 million impacted individuals in 2022.”36 89. “Healthcare organi[z]ations are rich targets for cybercriminals because they hold a large amount of sensitive patient data. This data can be used to commit identity theft or fraud or sold on the black market. Hackers can access this data in many ways, including phishing emails, malware, and unsecured networks.”37 90. It is no secret that “[h]ealthcare data breaches are reaching record highs. Indeed, healthcare now sees more cyberattacks than any other industry. Fully one-third of all cyberattacks are aimed at healthcare institutions. Why? Because healthcare is a valuable and vulnerable target. Hospitals and healthcare institutions are a prime target for cybercrime due to the vast amount of sensitive data they hold.”38 91. The health industry is frequently recognized as one of the most vulnerable industries for a cyberattack.39 92. Defendant should have been aware, and indeed was aware, that it was at risk of a data breach that could expose the Private Information that it solicited, collected, stored, and maintained, especially given the rise of healthcare data breaches. 36 This Year’s Largest Healthcare Data Breaches, Health IT Security (Dec. 26, 2023), https://healthitsecurity.com/features/this-years-largest-healthcare-data-breaches. 37 Troy Beamer, What Industries Are Most Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks In 2024?, TechNews (Feb. 27, 2024), https://www.techbusinessnews.com.au/what-industries-are-mostvulnerable-to-cyberattacks-in-2022/. 38 What Industries Are Most Vulnerable to Cyberattacks?, PSM, https://www.psmpartners.com/blog/most-targeted-industries-for-cyber-attacks/ 39 See, e.g., id.; Liudmyla Pryimenko, The 7 Industries Most Vulnerable to Cyberattacks, Ekran (Mar. 25, 2024), https://www.ekransystem.com/en/blog/5-industries-most-risk-of-databreaches; Ani Petrosyan, Distribution of cyberattacks across worldwide industries in 2023, Statista (Mar. 22, 2024), https://www.statista.com/statistics/1315805/cyber-attacks-topindustries-worldwide/; 6 Industries Most Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks, WGU (Aug. 3, 2021), https://www.wgu.edu/blog/6-industries-most-vulnerable-cyber-attacks2108.html. 22 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 93. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 23 of 59 PageID 23 Defendant was aware, or should have been aware, of the risks and harm that could result from inadequate data security. 94. Despite their assurances to patients regarding safeguarding PII and PHI, Defendant negligently failed to implement adequate security measures to safeguard the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members. E. Defendant Failed to Comply with Federal Trade Commission Guidelines, HIPAA, and Industry Standards for Cybersecurity. 95. Data breaches are preventable.40 “In almost all cases, the data breaches that occurred could have been prevented by proper planning and the correct design and implementation of appropriate security solutions.”41 “Organizations that collect, use, store, and share sensitive personal data must accept responsibility for protecting the information and ensuring that it is not compromised[.]”42 96. Most reported data breaches “are a result of lax security and the failure to create or enforce appropriate security policies, rules, and procedures. . . . Appropriate information security controls, including encryption, must be implemented and enforced in a rigorous and disciplined manner so that a data breach never occurs.”43 97. Here, many failures laid the groundwork for the Data Breach. 40 Lucy L. Thomson, Despite the Alarming Trends, Data Breaches Are Preventable, Data Breach and Encryption Handbook (Lucy Thompson, ed., 2012), available at https://lawcat.berkeley.edu/record/394088. 41 Id. at 17. 42 Id. at 28. 43 Id. 23 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 98. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 24 of 59 PageID 24 The FTC has published guidelines that establish reasonable data security practices for businesses.44 99. The FTC guidelines emphasize the importance of having a data security plan, regularly assessing risks to computer systems, and implementing safeguards to control such risks.45 100. The FTC guidelines establish that businesses should protect the confidential information that they keep; properly dispose of personal information that is no longer needed; encrypt information stored on computer networks; understand their network’s vulnerabilities; and implement policies for installing vendor-approved patches to correct security problems.46 101. The FTC guidelines also recommend that businesses utilize an intrusion detection system to expose a breach as soon as it occurs; monitor all incoming traffic for activity indicating hacking attempts; watch for large amounts of data being transmitted from the system; and have a response plan ready in the event of a breach.47 102. According to information and belief, Defendant failed to follow reasonable and necessary industry standards to prevent the Breach, including the FTC’s guidelines. 103. Upon information and belief, Defendant also failed to meet the minimum standards of any of the following frameworks: the NIST Cybersecurity Framework, NIST Special Publications 800-53, 53A, or 800-171; the Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program (FEDRAMP); or the Center for Internet Security’s Critical Security Controls (CIS CSC), which are well respected authorities in cybersecurity readiness. 44 Protecting Personal Information: A Guide for Business, FTC (Oct. 2016), available at https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/plain-language/pdf-0136_proteting-personalinformation.pdf. 45 Id. 46 Id. 47 Id. 24 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 104. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 25 of 59 PageID 25 As explained by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, “[p]revention is the most effective defense against ransomware and it is critical to take precautions for protection.”48 105. To prevent and detect the attack here, Defendant could and should have taken, as recommended by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the following measures: • Implemented an awareness and training program. Because end users are targets, patients and individuals should be aware of the threat of ransomware and how it is delivered. • Enabled strong spam filters to prevent phishing emails from reaching the end users and authenticate inbound email using technologies like Sender Policy Framework (SPF), Domain Message Authentication Reporting and Conformance (DMARC), and DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) to prevent email spoofing. • Scanned all incoming and outgoing emails to detect threats and filter executable files from reaching end users. • Configured firewalls to block access to known malicious IP addresses. • Patched operating systems, software, and firmware on devices. Consider using a centralized patch management system. • Set anti-virus and anti-malware programs to conduct regular scans automatically. • Managed the use of privileged accounts based on the principle of least privilege: no users should be assigned administrative access unless absolutely needed; and 48 See How to Protect Your Networks from RANSOMWARE, at 3, available at https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/ransomware-prevention-and-response-for-cisos.pdf/view. 25 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 26 of 59 PageID 26 those with a need for administrator accounts should only use them when necessary. • Configured access controls—including file, directory, and network share permissions—with least privilege in mind. If a user only needs to read specific files, the user should not have write access to those files, directories, or shares. • Disabled macro scripts from office files transmitted via email. Consider using Office Viewer software to open Microsoft Office files transmitted via email instead of full office suite applications. • Implemented Software Restriction Policies (SRP) or other controls to prevent programs from executing from common ransomware locations, such as temporary folders supporting popular Internet browsers or compression/decompression programs, including the AppData/LocalAppData folder. • Considered disabling Remote Desktop protocol (RDP) if it is not being used. • Used application whitelisting, which only allows systems to execute programs known and permitted by security policy. • Executed operating system environments or specific programs in a virtualized environment. • Categorized data based on organizational value and implement physical and logical separation of networks and data for different organizational units.49 106. 49 According to information and belief, Defendant failed to do any of the above. Id. at 3–4. 26 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 107. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 27 of 59 PageID 27 To prevent and detect ransomware attacks, Defendant could and should have recommended its patients, as recommended by the United States Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency, take the following measures: • Updated and patched your computer. Ensure your applications and operating systems (OSs) have been updated with the latest patches. Vulnerable applications and OSs are the target of most ransomware attacks. • Used caution with links and when entering website addresses. Be careful when clicking directly on links in emails, even if the sender appears to be someone you know. Attempt to independently verify website addresses (e.g., contact your organization’s helpdesk, search the internet for the sender organization’s website or the topic mentioned in the email). Pay attention to the website addresses you click on, as well as those you enter yourself. Malicious website addresses often appear almost identical to legitimate sites, often using a slight variation in spelling or a different domain (e.g., .com instead of .net). • Opened email attachments with caution. Be wary of opening email attachments, even from senders you think you know, particularly when attachments are compressed files or ZIP files. • Kept your personal information safe. Check a website’s security to ensure the information you submit is encrypted before you provide it. • Verified email senders. If you are unsure whether or not an email is legitimate, try to verify the email’s legitimacy by contacting the sender directly. Do not click on any links in the email. If possible, use a previous (legitimate) email to 27 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 28 of 59 PageID 28 ensure the contact information you have for the sender is authentic before you contact them. • Inform yourself. Keep yourself informed about recent cybersecurity threats and up to date on ransomware techniques. You can find information about known phishing attacks on the Anti-Phishing Working Group website. You may also want to sign up for CISA product notifications, which will alert you when a new Alert, Analysis Report, Bulletin, Current Activity, or Tip has been published. • Used and maintain preventative software programs. Install antivirus software, firewalls, and email filters—and keep them updated—to reduce malicious network traffic.50 108. In addition, to prevent and detect the Data Breach, Defendant could and should have implemented, as recommended by the Microsoft Threat Protection Intelligence Team, the following measures: • • Harden internet-facing assets - Apply latest security updates - Use threat and vulnerability management - Perform regular audits Thoroughly investigate and remediate alerts. - Prioritize and treat commodity malware infections as potential full compromise of the system 50 See Protecting Against Ransomware, CYBERSECURITY & INFRASTRUCTURE SECURITY AGENCY (revised Sept. 2, 2021), https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/news/protecting-againstransomware (internal citations omitted). 28 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K • Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 29 of 59 PageID 29 Include IT professionals in security discussions. - Ensure collaboration among security operations, security administrators, and information technology administrators to configure servers and other endpoints securely • Build and maintain credential hygiene - Use multifactor authentication or network level authentication and enforce strong, randomized, just-in-time local administrator passwords • • Apply principle of least-privilege - Monitor for adversarial activities - Hunt for brute force attempts - Monitor for cleanup of Event Logs - Analyze logon events Harden infrastructure - Utilize Windows Defender Firewall - Enable tamper protection - Enable cloud-delivered protection - Turn on attack surface reduction rules and Antimalware Scan Interface for Office Visual Basic for Applications51 109. Given that Defendant was storing the Private Information of thousands of individuals, Defendant could and should have implemented all of the above measures to prevent 51 See Human-operated ransomware attacks: A preventable disaster, MICROSOFT THREAT Intelligence (Mar 5, 2020), https://www.microsoft.com/security/blog/2020/03/05/humanoperated-ransomware-attacks-a-preventable-disaster/. 29 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 30 of 59 PageID 30 and detect cyberattacks. However, Defendant failed to do so because an unknown third-party was able to gain access to Defendant’s inadequately secured network and systems and exfiltrate the sensitive Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members. 110. Specifically, among other failures, Defendant had far too much confidential unencrypted information held on its systems. Such Private Information should have been segregated into an encrypted system.52 111. Moreover, it is well-established industry standard practice for a business to dispose of confidential Private Information once it is no longer needed.53 112. The FTC has repeatedly emphasized the importance of disposing of unnecessary Private Information: “Keep sensitive data in your system only as long as you have a business reason to have it. Once that business need is over, properly dispose of it. If it’s not on your system, it can’t be stolen by hackers.”54 Rather than following this basic standard of care, Defendant kept thousands of current and former patients’ unencrypted Private Information on its inadequately secured systems indefinitely. 113. In sum, the Data Breach could have been easily prevented through standard practices like the use of industry standard network segmentation and encryption of all Private Information—which Defendant negligently failed to do. 52 See Adnan Raja, How to Safeguard Your Business Data With Encryption, DATAINSIDER (Aug. 14, 2018), https://digitalguardian.com/blog/how-safeguard-your-business-data-encryption. 53 See Protecting Personal Information: A Guide for Business, FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION (Oct. 2016), https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/protecting-personalinformation-guide-business. 54 Id. at 6. 30 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 114. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 31 of 59 PageID 31 Further, the scope of the Data Breach could have been dramatically reduced had Defendant utilized proper record retention and destruction practices—but Defendant negligently did no such thing. 115. As a business that handles patient medical data and provides healthcare services to patients, Defendant is a covered entity under HIPAA. 45 C.F.R. § 160.103. Defendant has publicly acknowledged that it is a covered entity subject to the HIPAA Privacy, Security, and Breach Notification Rules. 116. As a covered entity, Defendant is required to comply with the HIPAA Privacy Rule, 45 C.F.R. Part 160 and Part 164, Subparts A and E (“Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information”), and the HIPAA Security Rule, 45 C.F.R. Part 160 and Part 164, Subparts A and C (“Security Standards for the Protection of Electronic Protected Health Information”). 117. The HIPAA Security Rule requires Defendant to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of all electronic protected health information it creates, receives, maintains, or transmits; protect against any reasonably anticipated threats or hazards to the security or integrity of such information; protect against any reasonably anticipated uses or disclosures not permitted under the Privacy Rule; and ensure compliance by its workforce. 118. HIPAA requires Defendant to implement technical policies and procedures for electronic information systems that maintain electronic protected health information to allow access only to those persons or software programs that have been granted access rights. 45 C.F.R. § 164.312(a)(1). 31 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 119. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 32 of 59 PageID 32 The HIPAA Breach Notification Rule, 45 C.F.R. §§ 164.400–414, further requires Defendant to provide notice of a breach to each affected individual without unreasonable delay and in no case later than 60 days following discovery of the breach. 120. Some or all of the patient information at issue in this action constitutes “protected health information” within the meaning of HIPAA, and Defendant’s failure to safeguard it violated the standards of care established by HIPAA and its implementing regulations. F. Common Injuries and Damages. 121. As a result of Defendant’s ineffective and inadequate data security practices, the Data Breach, and the foreseeable consequences of Private Information ending up in the possession of criminals, the risk of identity theft to the Plaintiff and Class Members has materialized and is imminent, and Plaintiff and Class Members have all sustained actual injuries and damages, including: (i) invasion of privacy; (ii) theft of their Private Information; (iii) lost or diminished value of Private Information; (iv) lost time associated with attempting to mitigate the actual consequences of the Data Breach; (v) loss of benefit of the bargain; (vi) lost opportunity costs associated with attempting to mitigate the actual consequences of the Data Breach; (vii) nominal damages; and (viii) the continued and certainly increased risk to their Private Information, which: (a) remains unencrypted and available for unauthorized third parties to access and abuse; and (b) remains backed up in Defendant’s possession and is subject to further unauthorized disclosures so long as Defendant fails to undertake appropriate and adequate measures to protect the Private Information. G. Loss of Time to Mitigate the Risks of Fraud and Identity Theft. 122. As a result of the recognized risk of identity theft, when a data breach occurs, and an individual is notified by a company that their Private Information was compromised, as in this 32 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 33 of 59 PageID 33 Data Breach, the reasonable person is expected to take steps and spend time to address the dangerous situation, learn about the breach, and otherwise mitigate the risk of becoming a victim of identity theft of fraud. Failure to spend time taking steps to review accounts or credit reports could expose the individual to greater financial harm—yet the asset of time has been lost. 123. Due to the actual and imminent risk of identity theft, Plaintiff and Class Members must monitor their financial accounts for many years to mitigate that harm. Identity theft protection and credit monitoring services are reasonable and necessary for Plaintiff and Class Members to protect themselves against fraud and identity theft. Plaintiff and Class Members will have to pay for these services for the rest of their lives now that their Private Information has been accessed and exposed in Defendant’s Breach. 124. Plaintiff and Class Members have spent time, and will spend additional time in the future, on a variety of prudent actions, such as placing freezes and alerts with credit reporting agencies, contacting financial institutions, closing or modifying financial accounts, changing passwords, reviewing and monitoring credit reports and accounts for unauthorized activity, and filing police reports, which may take years to discover. 125. These efforts are consistent with the steps that FTC recommends that data breach victims take several steps to protect their personal and financial information after a data breach, including: contacting one of the credit bureaus to place a fraud alert (consider an extended fraud alert that lasts for seven years if someone steals their identity), reviewing their credit reports, contacting companies to remove fraudulent charges from their accounts, placing a credit freeze on their credit, and correcting their credit reports. 126. Once Private Information is exposed, there is virtually no way to ensure that the exposed information has been fully recovered or contained against future misuse. For this reason, 33 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 34 of 59 PageID 34 Plaintiff and Class Members will need to maintain these heightened measures for years, and possibly their entire lives, because of Defendant’s conduct that caused the Data Breach. H. Future Cost of Credit and Identity Theft Monitoring is Reasonable and Necessary. 127. To date, Defendant has done nothing to provide Plaintiff and Class Members with relief for the damages they have suffered due to the Data Breach. 128. Given the type of targeted attack in this case and sophisticated criminal activity, the type of information involved, and the modus operandi of cybercriminals, there is a strong probability that entire batches of stolen information have been placed, or will be placed, on the dark web for sale and purchase by criminals intending to utilize the Private Information for identity theft crimes— e.g., opening bank accounts in the victims’ names to make purchases or to launder money; filing false tax returns; taking out loans or insurance; or filing false unemployment claims. 129. By accessing and obtaining the PII in the Breach, hackers have everything they need to commit fraud and identity theft. 130. Such fraud may be undetected until debt collection calls commence months, or even years later. An individual may not know that his or his information was used to file for unemployment benefits until law enforcement notifies the individual’s employer of the suspected fraud. Fraudulent tax returns are typically discovered only when an individual’s authentic tax return is rejected. 131. Furthermore, the information accessed and disseminated in the Data Breach is significantly more valuable than the loss of, for example, credit card information in a retailer data breach, where victims can easily cancel their cards and request a replacement.55 55 Jesse Damiani, Your Social Security Number Costs $4 On The Dark Web, New Report Finds, FORBES (Mar. 25, 2020), https://www.forbes.com/sites/jessedamiani/2020/03/25/your34 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 132. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 35 of 59 PageID 35 The information disclosed in this Data Breach is impossible to “close” and difficult, if not impossible, to change. 133. Consequently, Plaintiff and Class Members are at present and ongoing risk of fraud and identity theft for many years into the future. 134. The retail cost of credit monitoring and identity theft monitoring can cost $200 or more a year per Class Member. This is a reasonable and necessary cost to protect Class Members from the risk of identity theft that arose from Defendant’s Data Breach. This is a future cost for a minimum of five years that Plaintiff and Class Members would not need to bear but for Defendant’s failure to safeguard their Private Information. I. Plaintiff’s Individual Experience Plaintiff Denys Griaznov 135. Plaintiff Griaznov is a patient, directly or indirectly, of Defendant whose Private Information was provided to Defendant in connection with healthcare services Defendant or its affiliates provided to him. Plaintiff has undergone surgeries with Ascension, and since 2022 he has been insured through UnitedHealthcare under a plan provided by his employer. 136. Plaintiff Griaznov received a Notice Letter from Defendant dated November 13, 2026, informing him that files containing his personally identifiable information and protected health information, including his full name, medical record number, date of birth, date of service, medical provider name, health insurance group and policy numbers, other health insurance information, medical billing and payment for health services information, physical or medical conditions and/or diagnosis, medical procedure information, phone number, and address, may have social-securitynumber-costs-4-on-the-dark-web-new-report-finds/?sh=6a44b6d513f1 (last visited Feb. 11, 2025). 35 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 36 of 59 PageID 36 been subject to unauthorized access or acquisition in the Breach.56 137. Plaintiff entrusted his Private Information to Defendant with the reasonable expectation and mutual understanding that Defendant would keep his Private Information secure from unauthorized access. 138. By soliciting and accepting Plaintiff ’s Private Information, Defendant agreed to safeguard and protect it from unauthorized access and delete it after a reasonable time. 139. Plaintiff Griaznov would not have permitted his Private Information to be provided to Defendant had he known it would be kept using inadequate data security and vulnerable to a cyberattack. 140. Upon information and belief, Defendant was in possession of Plaintiff ’s Private Information before, during, and after the Data Breach. 141. As a result, Plaintiff Griaznov was injured by Defendant’s Data Breach. 142. Since the Data Breach, Plaintiff has experienced a significant increase in spam communications, including approximately five additional spam calls per week and countless spam letters and spam emails. Because Plaintiff blocks spam calls, the actual increase in spam calls directed to him is likely larger. Plaintiff has not received spam text messages or dark web alerts to date. Plaintiff has spent approximately two (2) hours to date responding to the Data Breach, and he expects to spend additional time responding to it in the future. 143. To mitigate the impact of the Data Breach, Plaintiff monitors his credit through the free credit-monitoring services offered by TransUnion, Experian, and Equifax, and he receives alerts regarding activity on his bank accounts and credit cards. Plaintiff does not currently pay for credit monitoring or identity theft protection services. To date, Plaintiff has not identified 56 Exhibit 1 36 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 37 of 59 PageID 37 fraudulent charges on his bank accounts or credit cards. 144. Plaintiff will be forced to spend additional time reviewing his credit reports and monitoring his accounts for the rest of his life. This is time spent which has been lost forever and cannot be recaptured. 145. Plaintiff places significant value in the security of his Private Information and does not readily disclose it. Plaintiff entrusted Defendant with his Private Information with the understanding that Defendant would keep his information secure and would employ reasonable and adequate data security measures to ensure that his Private Information would not be compromised. 146. Because of the Data Breach, there is no doubt Plaintiff ’s highly confidential Private Information is in the hands of cybercriminals. Reason being, the modus operandi of cybercriminals is to steal data they can exploit by selling on the dark web. As such, Plaintiff and the Class are at an imminent risk of identity theft and fraud. 147. Plaintiff Griaznov suffered actual injury from the exposure and theft of his Private Information—which violates his rights to privacy. 148. Plaintiff Griaznov suffered actual injury in the form of damages to and diminution in the value of his Private Information. After all, PII is a form of intangible property—property that Defendant was required to adequately protect and safeguard against unauthorized disclosure. 149. Due to Defendant’s Breach, Plaintiff will be forced to spend money to cover the cost of future credit monitoring and identity-theft monitoring, given the type of data accessed in the Breach and the risk that, upon information and belief, his information may be disclosed or sold to third parties, including on the dark web. The need for future monitoring is reasonable and necessary and is a consequence of Defendant’s breach of duty to maintain Plaintiff’s highly 37 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 38 of 59 PageID 38 sensitive Private Information, including his medical and health insurance information, secure and protected against unauthorized disclosure. 150. Plaintiff’s highly sensitive Private Information accessed in the Breach provides hackers with a clear ability to commit fraud. 151. Knowing that thieves intentionally targeted and accessed his Private Information, has caused Plaintiff great anxiety beyond mere worry. 152. The Data Breach has caused Plaintiff to suffer fear, anxiety, and stress, which has been compounded by Defendant’s delay in notifying him of the fact that his Private Information was accessed and/or acquired by criminals as a result of the Data Breach. 153. Plaintiff has never knowingly transmitted unencrypted Private Information over the internet or any other unsecured source. 154. As a direct and traceable result of the Data Breach, Plaintiff suffered actual injury and damages after his Private Information was compromised and stolen in the Data Breach, including, but not limited to: (i) lost time and money related to monitoring his accounts and credit reports for fraudulent activity; (ii) loss of privacy due to his Private Information being accessed and stolen by cybercriminals; (iii) loss of the benefit of his bargain because Defendant did not adequately protect his Private Information; (iv) emotional distress because identity thieves now possess his Private Information; (v) imminent and impending injury arising from the increased risk of fraud and identity theft now that his Private Information has been accessed by an unauthorized actor; (vi) diminution in the value of his Private Information, a form of intangible property that Defendant obtained from Plaintiff; and (vii) other economic and non-economic harm. 155. Plaintiff has been and will continue to be at a heightened and substantial risk of future identity theft and its attendant damages for years to come. This risk is certainly real and 38 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 39 of 59 PageID 39 impending, and is not speculative, given the highly sensitive nature of the Private Information stolen in the Data Breach. 156. Plaintiff has a continuing interest in ensuring that his Private Information, which, upon information and belief, remains in the possession of Defendant, is protected, and safeguarded from future data breaches. Absent Court intervention, Plaintiff ’s Private Information will be wholly unprotected and at-risk of future data breaches. V. 157. CLASS ACTION ALLEGATIONS Plaintiff incorporates by reference all preceding factual paragraphs as if fully restated here. 158. Plaintiff brings this action against Defendant individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23. Plaintiff asserts all claims on behalf of the class (the “Class”) defined as follows: All persons whose Private Information was accessed and/or compromised as a result of the Data Breach, including all persons that were sent a Notice Letter. 159. Excluded from the Class is Defendant, any entity in which Defendant has a controlling interest, and Defendant’s officers, directors, legal representatives, successors, subsidiaries, and assigns. Also excluded from the Class is any judge, justice, or judicial officer presiding over this matter and members of their immediate families and their judicial staff members. 160. Plaintiff reserves the right to amend or modify the above Class definition or to propose subclasses in subsequent pleadings and motions for class certification. 39 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 161. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 40 of 59 PageID 40 Plaintiff anticipates the issuance of notice setting forth the subject and nature of the instant action to the proposed Class. Upon information and belief, Defendant’s own business records or electronic media can be utilized for the notice process. 162. The proposed Class meets the requirements of FRCP 23. 163. Numerosity. Class Members are so numerous that joining all members is impracticable. Upon information and belief, the Class consists of tens of thousands of individuals affected by the Data Breach, and each Class Member is apparently identifiable within Defendant’s records. 164. Typicality. Plaintiff’s claims are typical of the claims of the Class because Plaintiff’s Private Information, like that of every other Class Member, was compromised in the Data Breach. Plaintiff and all members of the Class were injured by the same wrongful acts, practices, and omissions committed by Defendant, as described herein. Plaintiff’s claims therefore arise from the same practices or course of conduct that gives rise to the claims of all Class Members. 165. Adequacy of Representation. Plaintiff is an adequate representative of the Class because Plaintiff’s interests do not conflict with the interests of the Class. Plaintiff has retained counsel competent and highly experienced in data breach class action litigation, and Plaintiff and Plaintiff’s counsel intend to prosecute this action vigorously. The interests of the Class will be fairly and adequately protected by Plaintiff and his counsel. 166. Superiority. A class action is superior to other available means of fair and efficient adjudication of the claims of Plaintiff and the Class. The injury suffered by each individual Class Member is relatively small in comparison to the burden and expense of individual prosecution of complex and expensive litigation. It would be very difficult if not impossible for individual 40 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 41 of 59 PageID 41 members of the Class to effectively redress Defendant’s wrongdoing. Even if Class Members could afford such individual litigation, the court system could not. Individualized litigation presents potential for inconsistent or contradictory judgments. Individualized litigation increases the delay and expense to all parties, and to the court system, presented by the complex legal and factual issues of the case. By contrast, the class action device presents far fewer management difficulties and provides benefits of single adjudication, economy of scale, and comprehensive supervision by a single court. 167. Commonality and Predominance. Defendant engaged in a common course of conduct toward Plaintiff and Class Members, in that Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information was stored on the same network and unlawfully accessed in the same way. There are many questions of law and fact common to the claims of Plaintiff and the other members of the Class, and those questions predominate over any questions that may affect individual members of the Class. Common questions for the Class include: a. Whether Defendant engaged in the wrongful conduct alleged herein; b. Whether Defendant owed a duty to Plaintiff and Class Members to adequately protect their Private Information; c. Whether Defendant breached its duty to Plaintiff and Class Members to adequately protect their Private Information; d. Whether Defendant failed to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices appropriate to the nature and scope of the information compromised in the Data Breach; e. Whether Defendant’s data security systems prior to and during the Data Breach complied with applicable data security laws and regulations; 41 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 42 of 59 PageID 42 f. Whether Defendant’s data security systems prior to and during the Data Breach were consistent with industry standards; g. Whether Defendant knew or should have known that its computer and network security systems, or the computer and network security systems of its vendors, were vulnerable to cyberattacks; h. Whether Defendant’s conduct, including its failure to act, resulted in or was the proximate cause of the Data Breach; i. Whether Defendant was negligent in permitting unencrypted Private Information belonging to thousands of individuals to be stored within their network; j. Whether Defendant was negligent in failing to adhere to reasonable data retention policies; k. Whether Defendant breached implied contractual duties to Plaintiff and the Class to use reasonable care in protecting their Private Information; l. Whether Defendant was unjustly enriched by unlawfully retaining a benefit conferred upon it by Plaintiff and Class Members; m. Whether Defendant should have discovered the Data Breach sooner; n. Whether Defendant failed to adequately respond to the Data Breach, including failing to investigate it diligently and notify affected individuals in the most expedient time possible and without unreasonable delay, and whether this caused damages to Plaintiff and the Class; o. Whether Defendant continues to breach duties owed to Plaintiff and the Class; p. Whether Plaintiff and the Class suffered injuries as a proximate result of Defendant’s negligent actions or failures to act; 42 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 43 of 59 PageID 43 q. Whether Defendant was negligent in selecting, supervising, and/or monitoring vendors; r. Whether Plaintiff and the Class are entitled to recover damages, equitable relief, and other relief; and s. Whether Defendant’s actions alleged herein constitute gross negligence, and whether Plaintiff and Class Members are entitled to punitive damages. 168. Common sources of evidence may also be used to demonstrate Defendant’s unlawful conduct on a class-wide basis, including, but not limited to, documents and testimony about its data and cybersecurity measures (or lack thereof); testing and other methods that can prove Defendant’s data and cybersecurity systems have been or remain inadequate; documents and testimony about the source, cause, and extent of the Data Breach; and documents and testimony about any remedial efforts undertaken as a result of the Data Breach 169. The nature of this action and the nature of laws available to Plaintiff and Class Members make the use of the class action device a particularly efficient and appropriate procedure to afford relief to Plaintiff and Class Members for the wrongs alleged because Defendant would necessarily gain an unconscionable advantage since it would be able to exploit and overwhelm the limited resources of each individual Class Member with superior financial and legal resources; the costs of individual suits could unreasonably consume the amounts that would be recovered; proof of a common course of conduct to which Plaintiff were exposed are representatives of that experienced by the Class and will establish the right of each Class Member to recover on the cause of action alleged; and individual actions would create a risk of inconsistent results and would be unnecessary and duplicative of this litigation. 43 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 170. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 44 of 59 PageID 44 The litigation of the claims brought herein is manageable. Defendant’s uniform conduct, the consistent provisions of the relevant laws, and the ascertainable identities of Class Members demonstrate that there would be no significant manageability problems with prosecuting this lawsuit as a class action. 171. Adequate notice can be given to Class Members directly using information maintained in Defendant’s records. 172. Policies Generally Applicable to the Class: This class action is also appropriate for certification because Defendant acted or refused to act on grounds generally applicable to the Class, thereby requiring the Court’s imposition of uniform relief to ensure compatible standards of conduct toward the Class Members and making final injunctive relief and corresponding declaratory relief appropriate with respect to the Class as a whole. Defendant’s policies challenged herein apply to and affect Class Members uniformly and Plaintiff’s challenge of these policies hinges on Defendant’s conduct with respect to the Class as a whole, not on facts or law applicable only to Plaintiff. 173. Finally, all members of the proposed Class are readily ascertainable. Defendant has access to Class Members’ names and addresses. VI. CAUSES OF ACTION FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION NEGLIGENCE (On Behalf of Plaintiff and the Class) 174. Plaintiff re-alleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1-173 as if fully restated here. 175. Defendant solicited, collected, stored, and maintained the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members on inadequately secured computer systems and networks. 44 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 176. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 45 of 59 PageID 45 Upon accepting and storing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information on its computer systems and networks, Defendant undertook and owed a duty to Plaintiff and Class Members to exercise reasonable care in obtaining, retaining, securing, safeguarding, deleting, and protecting their Private Information from unauthorized access and disclosure. 177. Defendant owed a duty of care to Plaintiff and Class Members to provide data security consistent with industry standards and other requirements discussed herein, and to ensure that its computer systems and networks, and the personnel responsible for them, adequately protected the Private Information. 178. Defendant’s duty included a responsibility to implement processes by which it could detect a breach of its security systems in a reasonably expeditious period of time and to give prompt notice to those affected in the case of a data breach. 179. Defendant had full knowledge of the sensitivity of the Private Information in its possession and the types of harm that Plaintiff and Class Members could and would suffer if the Private Information was wrongfully accessed or disclosed. Plaintiff and Class Members were therefore the foreseeable victims of any inadequate data security practices. 180. Defendant’s duty to implement and maintain reasonable data security practices arose as a result of the special relationship that exists between Defendant and its patients, which is recognized by laws and regulations, including, but not limited to, the FTC Act, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (“HIPAA”) and common law. 181. Defendant was in a superior position to ensure its data security practices were sufficient to protect against the foreseeable risk of harm to Plaintiff and Class Members from a data breach. 45 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 182. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 46 of 59 PageID 46 Defendant knew Plaintiff and Class Members relied on it to protect their Private Information. Plaintiff and Class Members were not in a position to assess the data security practices used by Defendant. Because they had no means to identify Defendant’s security deficiencies, Plaintiff and Class Members had no opportunity to safeguard their Private Information from cybercriminals. Defendant exercised control over the Private Information stored on its systems and networks; accordingly, Defendant was best positioned and most capable of preventing the harms caused by the Data Breach. 183. Defendant was aware, or should have been aware, of the fact that cybercriminals routinely target entities storing PII through cyberattacks in an attempt to steal valuable Private Information. In other words, Defendant knew of a foreseeable risk to its data security systems but failed to implement reasonable security measures. 184. Defendant owed Plaintiff and Class Members a common law duty to use reasonable care to avoid causing foreseeable risk of harm to Plaintiff and the Class when obtaining, storing, using, and managing their Private Information, including taking action to reasonably safeguard or delete such data and providing notification to Plaintiff and Class Members of any breach in a timely manner so that appropriate action could be taken to minimize losses. 185. Defendant’s duty extended to protecting Plaintiff and the Class from the risk of foreseeable criminal conduct of third parties, which has been recognized in situations where the actor’s own conduct or misconduct exposes another to such risk, or defeats protections put in place to guard against that risk, or where the parties are in a special relationship. See Restatement (Second) of Torts § 302B. 186. Defendant had a duty to implement and maintain reasonable data security practices pursuant to Section 5 of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a), which prohibits “unfair . . . practices in 46 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 47 of 59 PageID 47 or affecting commerce,” including, as interpreted and enforced by the FTC, the unfair practice of failing to use reasonable measures to protect sensitive and confidential data. 187. The FTC Act prohibits “unfair practices in or affecting commerce,” including, as interpreted and enforced by the FTC, the unfair act or practice by businesses, such as Defendant, of failing to use reasonable measures to protect PII. The FTC publications and orders described above also formed part of the basis of Defendant’s duty in this regard. 188. Defendant also had a duty to use reasonable security measures under HIPAA, which requires covered entities, such as Defendant, to “reasonably protect” confidential data from “any intentional or unintentional use or disclosure” and to “have in place appropriate administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the privacy of protected health information.” 45 C.F.R. § 164.530(c)(1). Some or all of the information at issue in this action constitutes “protected health information” within the meaning of HIPAA. 189. Defendant’s failures to comply with HIPAA and its implementing regulations, including 45 C.F.R. §§ 164.306, 164.308, 164.312, and 164.530, constitute negligence per se. 190. Defendant solicited, collected, stored, and maintained Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information as part of their regular business, which affects commerce. 191. Defendant violated the FTC Act by failing to use reasonable measures to protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information and by failing to comply with applicable industry standards, as described herein. 192. Defendant breached its duties to Plaintiff and the Class under the FTC Act by failing to implement and maintain fair, reasonable, and adequate data security practices to safeguard Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, and by failing to provide prompt notice of the Data Breach without unreasonable delay. 47 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 193. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 48 of 59 PageID 48 Defendant’s multiple failures to comply with applicable laws and regulations constitute negligence per se. 194. Plaintiff and the Class are within the class of persons that the FTC Act was intended to protect. 195. The harm that occurred as a result of the Data Breach is the type of harm the FTC Act was intended to guard against. The FTC has pursued enforcement actions against businesses, like Defendant, that fail to employ reasonable data security measures and avoid unfair and deceptive practices, causing the same harm as that suffered by Plaintiff and the Class. 196. Defendant breached its duties to Plaintiff and the Class by unreasonably delaying and failing to provide notice of the Data Breach expeditiously and/or as soon as practicable to Plaintiff and the Class. 197. Defendant’s violations of the FTC Act constitute negligence per se. 198. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s negligence per se, Plaintiff and the Class have suffered, and continue to suffer, damages arising from the Data Breach, as alleged above. 199. The injury and harm that Plaintiff and Class members suffered (as alleged above) was the direct and proximate result of Defendant’s negligence per se. 200. Defendant breached its duties, and thus was negligent, by failing to use reasonable measures to protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information. 201. The specific negligent acts and omissions committed by Defendant include, but are not limited to: a. Failing to adopt, implement, and maintain adequate data security measures to safeguard Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information; 48 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 49 of 59 PageID 49 b. Failing to adequately monitor the security of its networks and systems; c. Failing to ensure its email systems had plans in place to maintain reasonable data security safeguards; d. Failing to implement and maintain adequate mitigation policies and procedures; e. Allowing unauthorized access to Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information; f. Failing to detect in a timely manner that Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information had been compromised; and g. Failing to timely notify Plaintiff and Class Members about the Data Breach so they could take appropriate steps to mitigate the potential for identity theft and other damages. 202. Defendant’s willful failure to abide by its duties to Plaintiff and Class Members was wrongful, reckless, and grossly negligent considering the foreseeable risks and known threats. 203. It was foreseeable that Defendant’s failure to use reasonable measures to protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information would result in injury to Plaintiff and Class Members. 204. Furthermore, the breach of security was reasonably foreseeable given the known high frequency of cyberattacks and data breaches in the healthcare industry. 205. But for Defendant’s negligent conduct and breach of the duties described above, Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information would not have been compromised. 206. It was therefore foreseeable that Defendant’s failure to adequately safeguard Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information would cause them one or more types of injury. 49 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 207. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 50 of 59 PageID 50 As a healthcare entity in custody of the Private Information of its patients, Defendant knew, or reasonably should have known, the importance of safeguarding the Private Information entrusted to it by Plaintiff and Class Members, and of the foreseeable consequences that would occur if its data security systems were breached, including, specifically, the significant costs that would be imposed on Plaintiff and Class Members as a result of a breach. 208. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s negligent conduct, including, but not limited to, its failure to implement and maintain reasonable data security practices and procedures as described above, Plaintiff and the Class have suffered damages and are at imminent risk of additional harms and damages (as alleged above). 209. Through Defendant’s acts and omissions described herein, including but not limited to Defendant’s failure to protect the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members from being stolen and misused, Defendant unlawfully breached its duty to use reasonable care to adequately protect and secure the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members while it was within Defendant’s possession and control. 210. Further, through its failure to provide timely and clear notification of the Data Breach to Plaintiff and Class Members, Defendant prevented Plaintiff and Class Members from taking meaningful, proactive steps to secure their Private Information and mitigate the impact of the Data Breach. 211. Plaintiff and Class Members could have taken actions earlier had they been timely notified of the Data Breach. Yet, Defendant delayed in noticing Plaintiff and Class Members of the Breach. 50 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 212. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 51 of 59 PageID 51 Plaintiff and Class Members could have enrolled in credit monitoring, instituted credit freezes, and changed their passwords, among other things, had they been alerted to the Data Breach more quickly. 213. Plaintiff and Class Members suffered harm from Defendant’s delay in notifying them of the Data Breach. 214. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s conduct, including, but not limited to, Defendant’s failure to implement and maintain reasonable data security practices and procedures, Plaintiff and Class Members have suffered or will suffer injury and damages, including, but not limited to: (i) the loss of the opportunity to determine for themselves how their Private Information is used; (ii) the publication and theft of their Private Information; (iii) out-ofpocket expenses associated with the prevention, detection, and recovery from identity theft, fraud, and/or unauthorized use of their Private Information, including the need for substantial credit monitoring and identity protection services for an extended period of time; (iv) lost time and opportunity costs associated with efforts expended to address and mitigate the actual and future consequences of the Data Breach, including, but not limited to, efforts spent researching how to prevent, detect, contest and recover from fraud and identity theft; (v) costs associated with placing freezes on credit reports and password protections; (vi) anxiety, emotional distress, loss of privacy, and other economic and non-economic losses; (vii) the continued risk to their Private Information, which remains in Defendant’s possession and is subject to further unauthorized disclosures so long as Defendant fails to undertake appropriate and adequate measures to protect the Private Information in its continued possession; and (viii) future costs in terms of time, effort, and money that will be expended to prevent, detect, contest, and repair the inevitable and continuing consequences of compromised Private Information for the rest of their lives. Thus, Plaintiff and 51 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 52 of 59 PageID 52 the Class are entitled to damages in an amount to be proven at trial. 215. The damages Plaintiff and the Class have suffered and will suffer (as alleged above) were and are the direct and proximate result of Defendant’s negligent conduct. 216. Plaintiff and the Class have suffered cognizable injuries and are entitled to actual and punitive damages in an amount to be proven at trial. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION BREACH OF IMPLIED CONTRACT (On Behalf of Plaintiff and the Class) 217. Plaintiff re-alleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1-173 as if fully restated here. 218. Plaintiff and Class Members were required to provide their Private Information to Defendant, directly or indirectly, in order to receive healthcare services. Plaintiff and Class Members paid money, or money was paid on their behalf, to Defendant in exchange for services. 219. Defendant solicited and accepted possession of Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information for the purpose of providing services to Plaintiff and Class Members. 220. In delivering, directly or indirectly, their Private Information to Defendant and paying for services, Plaintiff and Class Members intended and understood that Defendant would adequately safeguard their Private Information. 221. Plaintiff and Class Members reasonably expected that the Private Information they entrusted to Defendant, in order to receive its services, would remain confidential and would not be shared or disclosed to criminal third parties. 222. Plaintiff and Defendant had a mutual understanding that Defendant would implement and maintain adequate and reasonable data security practices and procedures to protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ sensitive Private Information. Plaintiff and Defendant also shared 52 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 53 of 59 PageID 53 an expectation and understanding that Defendant would not share or disclose, whether intentionally or unintentionally, the sensitive Private Information in its possession and control. 223. Based on Defendant’s representations, legal obligations, and acceptance of Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, Defendant had a duty to safeguard the Private Information in its possession through the use of reasonable data security practices. 224. When Plaintiff and Class Members paid money and provided their Private Information to Defendant, either directly or indirectly, in exchange for goods or services, they entered into implied contracts with Defendant. 225. Defendant entered into implied contracts with Plaintiff and the Class under which Defendant agreed to comply with its statutory and common law duties to safeguard and protect Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information and to timely notify Plaintiff and Class Members of a data breach. In exchange, Plaintiff and Class Members provided their Private Information to Defendant and paid money to Defendant, directly or indirectly, which a portion was to ensure that Defendant maintained adequate security measures to protect the PII and PHI of Plaintiff and the Class. 226. The implied promise of confidentiality includes consideration beyond those pre- existing duties owed under Section 5 of the FTC Act and other state and federal regulations. The additional consideration included implied promises to take adequate steps to comply with specific industry data security standards and FTC guidelines on data security. 227. The implied promises include, but are not limited to: (i) taking steps to ensure any agents or vendors who are granted access to Private Information protect the confidentiality of that information; (ii) taking steps to ensure that Private Information in the possession and control of Defendant, its agents, and/or vendors is restricted and limited to achieve an authorized business 53 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 54 of 59 PageID 54 purpose; (iii) restricting access to qualified and trained agents and/or vendors; (iv) designing and implementing appropriate retention policies to protect the Private Information from unauthorized access and disclosure; (v) applying or requiring proper encryption of the Private Information; (vi) requiring multifactor authentication for access to the Private Information; and (vii) other steps necessary to protect against foreseeable data breaches. 228. Plaintiff and Class Members would not have entrusted their Private Information to Defendant in the absence of such implied contracts. 229. Defendant recognized that Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information is highly sensitive and must be protected, and that this protection was of material importance to Plaintiff and Class Members. 230. Had Defendant disclosed to Plaintiff and Class Members that it did not have adequate data security practices to secure their Private Information, Plaintiff and Class Members would not have provided their Private Information to Defendant. 231. Plaintiff and Class Members fully performed their obligations under the implied contracts with Defendant. 232. Defendant breached the implied contracts with Plaintiff and Class Members by failing to safeguard Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information and by failing to provide them with timely and accurate notice of the Data Breach. 233. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s breach of the implied contracts, Plaintiff and Class Members have suffered damages, including foreseeable consequential damages that Defendant knew about when they solicited and collected Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information. 54 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K 234. Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 55 of 59 PageID 55 Plaintiff and the Class have suffered injuries as described above, and are entitled to actual and punitive damages, statutory damages, and reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs, in an amount to be proven at trial. THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION UNJUST ENRICHMENT (On Behalf of Plaintiff and the Class) 235. Plaintiff re-alleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1-173 as if fully restated here. 236. Plaintiff alleges this claim in the alternative to his breach of implied contract claim. 237. Plaintiff and the Class provided their Private Information to Defendant in order to receive services. 238. By conferring their Private Information to Defendant, Plaintiff and Class Members reasonably understood Defendant would be responsible for securing their Private Information from unauthorized access and disclosure. 239. Upon information and belief, Defendant funds its data security measures entirely from its general revenue, including revenues derived from payments made by or on behalf of Plaintiff and Class Members for Defendant’s services. 240. As such, a portion of the revenue generated from the payments made by or on behalf of Plaintiff and Class Members is to be used to provide a reasonable level of data security, and the amount of the revenue generated that is allocated to data security is known to Defendant. 241. Defendant failed to secure Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information and, therefore, did not fully compensate Plaintiff or Class Members for the value that their Private Information provided. 242. Protecting the Private Information of Plaintiff and Class Members is integral to 55 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 56 of 59 PageID 56 Defendant’s business. Without their Private Information, Defendant would be unable to provide services comprising Defendant’s core business. 243. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information have monetary value. 244. Plaintiff and Class Members directly conferred a monetary benefit on Defendant by supplying their Private Information, from which Defendant derives its business, and which should have been protected with adequate data security. 245. Defendant solicited, collected, stored, and maintained Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information, and as such, Defendant had direct knowledge of the monetary benefits conferred upon it by Plaintiff and the Class. Defendant profited from these transactions and used Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information for business purposes. 246. Indeed, Plaintiff and Class Members who were patients of Defendant paid money, directly or indirectly, to Defendant for its services and therefore conferred a benefit unto Defendant. 247. Defendant appreciated that a monetary benefit was being conferred upon them by Plaintiff and Class Members and accepted that monetary benefit. 248. Under the facts and circumstances outlined above, however, it is inequitable for Defendant to retain that benefit without payment of the value thereof. 249. Defendant enriched itself by saving the costs it reasonably should have expended on data security measures to secure Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information. 250. Instead of providing a reasonable level of security that would have prevented the Data Breach, Defendant instead calculated to increase its own profits to the detriment of Plaintiff and Class Members by utilizing cheaper, ineffective security measures. Plaintiff and Class Members, on the other hand, suffered as a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s decision to 56 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 57 of 59 PageID 57 prioritize its own profits over the requisite data security. 251. Under the principles of equity and good conscience, Defendant should not be permitted to retain the monetary benefit belonging to Plaintiff and Class Members, because Defendant failed to implement appropriate data management and security measures. 252. Defendant acquired Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Private Information through inequitable means in that they failed to disclose their inadequate data security practices, as previously alleged. 253. If Plaintiff and Class Members knew that Defendant had not secured their Private Information, they would not have allowed Defendant to collect their Private Information. 254. Plaintiff and Class Members have no adequate remedy at law. 255. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s conduct, Plaintiff and Class Members have suffered or will suffer injury, including, but not limited to: (i) actual identity theft and fraud; (ii) loss of the opportunity to control how their Private Information is used; (iii) the compromise, publication, and/or theft of their Private Information; (iv) out-of-pocket expenses associated with the prevention, detection, and recovery from identity theft, fraud, and/or unauthorized use of their Private Information; (v) lost time and opportunity costs associated with efforts to mitigate the actual and future consequences of the Data Breach, including, but not limited to, effort and time spent researching how to prevent, detect, contest, and recover from identity theft; (vi) the continued risk to their Private Information, which remains in Defendant’s possession and is subject to further unauthorized disclosures so long as Defendant fails to undertake appropriate and adequate measures to protect the Private Information in their continued possession; and/or (vii) future costs in terms of time, effort, and money that will be expended to 57 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 58 of 59 PageID 58 prevent, detect, contest, and repair the impact of the Data Breach for the remainder of the lives of Plaintiff and Class Members. 256. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s conduct, Plaintiff and Class Members have suffered and will continue to suffer other forms of injury and/or harm. 257. Defendant should be compelled to disgorge into a common fund or constructive trust, for the benefit of Plaintiff and Class Members, all gains that it unjustly received. VII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF WHEREFORE, Plaintiff and the Class pray for judgment against Defendant as follows: a. For an order determining that this action is properly brought as a class action and certifying Plaintiff as the representative of the Class and his counsel as Class Counsel; b. A judgment in favor of Plaintiff and the Class awarding them appropriate monetary relief, including compensatory damages, punitive damages, attorney fees, expenses, costs, and such other and further relief as is just and proper; c. An order providing injunctive and other equitable relief as necessary to protect the interests of the Class as requested herein; d. An order requiring Defendant to pay the costs involved in notifying the Class Members about the judgment and administering the claims process; e. A judgment in favor of Plaintiff and the Class awarding them pre-judgment and post-judgment interest, reasonable attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses as allowable by law; and f. An award of such other and further relief as this Court may deem just and proper. 58 Case 3:26-cv-04097-K Document 1 Filed 11/20/26 Page 59 of 59 PageID 59 DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury on any and all issues raised in this Class Action Complaint so triable as of right. Dated: November 20, 2026 Respectfully submitted, /s/ William B. Federman William B. Federman Tex. Bar No. 00794935 Anushe Zebal Tex. Bar No. 24143548 FEDERMAN & SHERWOOD 4131 N. Central Expressway Suite 900 Dallas, TX 75204 T: (800) 237-1277 E: wbf@federmanlaw.com E: anz@federmanlaw.com Counsel for Plaintiff and Putative Class 59